ysm破解利好玩家了吗？ -没有，这个破解不会让玩家获得免费的模型，也不会利好导购，而是会让创作者的工程流出，被有心之人利用改造牟利。加密的ysm模型完全不会影响玩家正常使用，而且许多创作者会单独售卖模型工程。 943清掉一个贡献者是光速切割、又当又立？ -该贡献者提供了优质的模型相关系统，但是以个人名义在制作r18模型。ysm的维护主要仍是943在进行，说ysm开发组制作r18模型是完全荒谬的。在删除该条目的时候，ysm相关组也与此贡献者协商达成一致。

试想一下，一家上市公司声明自己不做灰产，但是某天一个灰产大佬提供了一个优质、非灰产的解决方案并被公司采纳。那么我问你，把这位大佬写进贡献清单应不应该？难道公司就变成了灰产公司？后来出现了一些争议，于是公司与大佬协商，为了减少影响从贡献清单中删除大佬的条目，双方达成共识。这难道是切割，是又当又立？ 卖模型违反EULA？破解天经地义？ -ysm模型属于ysm的附属，本质上完全是独立于Minecraft的美术资产，售卖这些独立的美术资产完全合法合规，加密是保护创作者和消费者的权益。破解ysm只会侵害购买者和创作者的权益，你不能只在自己的权益被侵害的时候才想起DMCA和CC协议。 不要被当枪使，某些人口口声说的“开源精神”不过只是方便自己。 附：MinecraftEULA相关条款 Summary-第五条： Do not distribute or make commercial use of anything we've made without our permission. 细则"what you can and can’t do with Minecraft software and content":

...

Otherwise we are quite relaxed about what you do - in fact we really encourage you to do cool stuff - but just don't do those things that we say you can't. We’ve put together detailed Minecraft Usage Guidelines as to how you can or cannot do things using what we’ve made, including screenshots and recorded videos of our games. These Minecraft Usage Guidelines are extra permissions that we give to the community to encourage creativity and community, but we reserve the right to change them or withdraw permissions, especially if we see people exploiting or abusing these permissions. The Minecraft Usage Guidelines often change, and we have the right to withdraw the permissions given in them at any time without notice.

上文的Usage Guidelines: https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/usage-guidelines