Ep 18-1: Mars
EOROF
2021年06月19日 01:35
收录于文集
共155篇

Transcript

Gary Jordan (Host): Houston, we have a podcast. Welcome to the official podcast of the NASA Johnson Space Center, Episode 18: Mars. I’m Gary Jordan and I’ll be your host today. So this is the podcast where we bring in the experts-- NASA scientists, engineers, astronauts-- bring them right here on the show and talk about all of the coolest parts about space. So today we’re talking about Mars with Doug Archer, which I feel like is a good topic to bring up now because next week, NASA is launching a brand new podcast called “Gravity Assist” hosted by Dr. Jim Green, NASA’s Director of Planetary Science. The show will focus on planets, and the solar system, and beyond. So if you love planetary science, definitely subscribe to that show. It's going to start with a ten-part series on our solar system that starts with the Sun and goes all the way out to Pluto and beyond. I know I’m pretty excited about it. So as sort of a taste of what you’re going to get on “Gravity Assist,” Doug Archer will talk about the fourth planet from the Sun today on “Houston, we have a podcast.” Doug is a planetary scientist at the NASA Johnson Space Center here in Houston, Texas. And we had a great discussion about the Red Planet-- what it’s made out of, what it’s like on the surface, and why it’s such an intriguing place for humans to visit in the next giant leap. So with no further delay, let’s go light speed and jump right ahead to our talk with Dr. Doug Archer. Enjoy.

[ music ]

>> T minus five seconds and counting-- mark. [ indistinct radio chatter ]

>> Houston, we have a podcast.

[ music ]

Host: So you’re a planetary scientist. That’s your title, right-- planetary scientist?

Doug Archer: Yep.

Host: So I’m guessing it’s exactly what it sounds like-- you know the science behind why a planet is the way it is-- why it’s a planet and how it works and all that kind of stuff. Your specialty is Mars.

Doug Archer: Yep, yeah, I’ve been working on Mars for about 13, 14 years now.

Host: Wow. So what was it that originally fascinated you with Mars?

Doug Archer: So like lots of kids, when I grew up I was interested in space or being a pilot or something like that, or an astronaut. But then when I was, I think, 16, I read a book called “the case for Mars: the plan to settle the red planet and why we must.” And it was written by a guy named Bob Zubrin, and he laid out this whole architecture for how we would get to Mars, the type of rocket that we would need, what the habitats would look like, how long it would take to get there-- just this whole architecture of how we would get to Mars, and then ultimately, the long term goal is turning Mars into a more earth-like place. But that’s like the super long term goal.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: So this book came out, again, I think, in 1996 or something like that, and there was this big cover article in “Newsweek” and other magazines-- it kind of made big news. And I just read the articles, read the book, and just got fascinated with the idea of human exploration of Mars, and then learned more about the planet Mars. And when I was an undergrad, I was trying to figure out what major I wanted to do, what I wanted to major in, and I was thinking about, “well, you know, I think I’m kind of good at this, and I’m kind of good at this.” But what I was really passionate about was Mars and Mars exploration. And I didn’t know how to make a career of that, because where I went to undergrad at Brigham Young University in Utah, we didn’t have any kind of space related program there. So I ended up just majoring in physics. I found a professor who was similarly interested in Mars, and another professor in the geology department who’d actually--

Host: At Brigham Young?

Doug Archer: Yeah, at BYU-- there just happened to be a few other kind of space enthusiasts there, Mars enthusiasts. So they kind of pointed me on the road, and so I took an introduction to planetary geology course as an undergrad, and just loved that. And they pointed me on the course of, “all right, here’s some courses to take to prepare for grad school, and this is where you should apply.” And one of the places that I applied was the university of Arizona, which has one of the few programs in planetary science in the country, or one of the few PhD programs. And I got accepted and started there in august of 2004. And the reason that I went there is that they had just won the contract from NASA to do the 2007 Mars phoenix scout mission.

Host: Huh.

Doug Archer: So I got to see-- so I went in, and my advisor was the principal investigator for that mission, so kind of the boss over the whole mission. So I went in as a first year grad student and worked on the phoenix project right after it had been selected. And so my career as a grad student spanned the right after selection, all of the design work, verification, all of that for phoenix, and then landing, surface operations, and then doing the science on the stuff that we learned on the surface. And the mission ended in late 2008. So I just kind of walked into this great opportunity of getting involved in an actual Mars mission as a graduate student, and just loved working on Mars, loved the mission operations aspect of it, and one of the most exciting times of my life has been the two times when I’ve been able to remotely witness a robot landing on Mars and just the absolute thrill that that is the 10 to 15 minutes of, okay, this is it. Everything comes down to this moment, and then the thrill of seeing the first pictures from these landing sites that no one has ever seen before. Like it is just an absolutely amazing experience to see these pictures coming in for the first time from another planet and just having that feeling of discovery and exploration.

Host: I can imagine, because you have such a passion for it, since you pursued it so far, getting a PhD. And in planetary science, being fascinated with planets and then being able to work on and learn from a robot that was actually on the surface of another planet.

Doug Archer: Yeah.

Host: That is crazy. That is awesome. So that makes me think-- why-- so your specialty is Mars, and that is a huge part of NASA’s journey to Mars, right-- we really want to put boots on that planet.

Doug Archer: Yeah.

Host: But why that planet? Obviously we have Venus, we have-- titan looks pretty cool, and Enceladus. What is it about Mars that’s so intriguing?

Doug Archer: So as far as the boots-- it all kind of comes back down to the boots on the ground aspect that you’re talking about. Like titan and Enceladus are very interesting places, Europa-- there’s other really cool places in the solar system, including if you’re looking for life outside of earth. There’s other places that you could go look. Mars is the planet that is the most likely to host life where humans can actually go. Like, we are years and probably decades and centuries away from being able to safely go to Enceladus or titan or Europa or whatever with people.

Host: That’s pretty far away.

Doug Archer: Yeah, we have the technology to get us to Mars, and I think that it is-- we know that in the Martian past Mars was a lot more earth-like than it is today. We don’t exactly know how that happened. It’s still an open question as to how Mars could have sustained this warmer climate, for various reasons that we could get into.

Host: Yeah.

Doug Archer: So we don’t exactly know why that’s the case, but we know from geologic evidence that Mars was warmer and wetter in the past than it is today, and we know from earth that pretty much as soon as life could have existed on earth, it did. So we don’t know how life originates, exactly, but again, from earth we say, hey, as soon as the conditions were right for life to exist, we find evidence of life. We know that those same conditions existed on Mars, so the question is can we go to a place where we can find evidence of a past-- more likely past but potential present life on Mars. And then as far as the astronauts, the astronauts will allow you to do a lot more science than robots will.

Host: Right, because it-- I mean, so we talked about this on a previous episode with Bill Foster about space communication.

Doug Archer: Okay.

Host: And how difficult that’s going to be. If you get a signal to Mars, it’s going to take 8 minutes, up to 40 minutes’ round trip to do anything.

Doug Archer: Yeah.

Host: But if a human was there, they can make decisions rapid-fire.

Doug Archer: Yeah.

Host: You can get a lot more done in a shorter amount of time. I’m guessing that’s like pretty much the basis of why humans are that much better-- probably also the observational aspect of it.

Doug Archer: Yeah, absolutely, both of those things together. So let me-- I’ll give you an anecdote to kind of show you the limitations of robotic exploration. And first I’ll say-- talk about the benefits of robotic exploration. First of all, it’s something that we can do today, right-- we’ve been doing it on Mars now for over 40 years. The Viking landers landed in late 1976. So we have a lot of experience operating robots on the surface of Mars, and they are very capable. Like, the rovers can hold a lot more stuff than astronauts can. They don’t have to continually go back to the the hab. You don’t have to send food. You don’t have to worry about oxygen.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: So it’s a lot simpler. However, robots are only as smart as the humans that program them.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: And because we have no capability of repairing or fixing something if it goes wrong, we’re very cautious about how we operate the rovers, or robots. And as you said, we have this communication issue built in that makes it so that-- you know, a lot of people think that when we’re operating the rovers on Mars, it’s a man or a woman sitting in a room somewhere with a joystick in front of a TV and driving the rover.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: But at its closest, Mars and earth are-- there’s a four-minute one-way light time delay between Mars and earth, so eight minutes round trip. And at their farthest away, it’s about 20 minutes one-way or 40 minutes round trip. So you can imagine, anything that you’re seeing is delayed by 40 minutes. So there’s no way-- in the worst case-- 8 minutes, best case-- there’s no way that you can do any kind of real time operations under those circumstances. So what we do is we plan a whole day at a time. So during the Martian night when the rover is asleep, we’re awake planning the next day. And when the rover wakes up, the first thing it does is kind of check in with earth and get the instructions for what it should be doing that day. And then it will go through the whole day of planned operations, and then go to sleep, and then the process repeats-- wakes up-- and so it sends back the data of what it did that day, we look at the data of what it did, how things went, and then plan the next day. So because of our conservatism, because we don’t want to break anything, and because the robots are only as smart as we make them, you’ll have funny instances where, for example, the phoenix lander, which we knew had a very limited lifetime because it was in the northern polar region-- so at some point, the sun was going to set and not rise again for six months. So there’s nothing that we could’ve done to make that mission last for years. We knew that going in.

Host: Because-- how cold does it get when the sun sets?

Doug Archer: When the sun sets for kind of months at a time, I think it can get down to like minus 130, which is the frost point for carbon dioxide.

Host: Fahrenheit?

Doug Archer: So the Martian atmosphere-- Celsius, sorry.  But at that point, they’re relatively similar. But so the Martian atmosphere is 95% carbon dioxide, and it gets so cold that the atmosphere starts condensing out onto the surface as dry ice. So our lander, at the end of the Martian northern winter, was buried under a meter of carbon dioxide ice.

Host: Okay, so no coming back from that.

Doug Archer: Yeah. So we took pictures with high res-- a high resolution camera around Mars, and it looks like one of the solar panels, which is kind of the size of a kitchen table on the lander-- it had two panels about that size, and then a lander itself that was about the same size. And it looks like one of the solar panels was broken by that.

Host: Oh.

Doug Archer: So we knew that there was almost no chance that we were going to survive to the next year. We knew that going in.

Host: But the polar ice caps are-- they’re super interesting. That’s why you sent it there, right?

Doug Archer: So we were just south of the permanent ice caps, but-- so there’s the seasonal cap of co2, and then water ice as well.

Host: Cool.

Doug Archer: But then the reason why we chose the location to send phoenix is that underneath-- or we saw from orbit the signature of water underneath soil. And we went to confirm that, and we did, in a few ways. One was just during the landing process. Our thrusters that we use to land safely blew off the covering of the soil or loose dirt right underneath the thrusters, and you can see this ice-cemented ground. Then we had a robotic arm to dig down, and found that depending on exactly where we dug, between 4 and 15 centimeters deep we found this ice layer where in a couple places it looked like it was almost pure water ice. And most of the area that we uncovered was ice-cemented soil. So you can imagine taking a dish full or dirt, adding water to it, and throwing it in the freezer. And at these temperatures or at the Martian temperatures that I was talking about earlier, it’s as hard as concrete.

Host: Really hard to dig, then, probably.

Doug Archer: Yeah, so we couldn’t dig into that. The best we could do, we could kind of scrape along the surface and collect what we scraped. But we also had a drill that could drill about a centimeter into the ice, and then we’d collect the tailings that came from the drill.

Host: Okay.

Doug Archer: But to get back to the human exploration plan, so one day on Mars, we’re digging with the phoenix lander-- and so what you do, right, you say, “okay, dig here, and then dump here.” So dig in this area that we define, and then dump off in some other area.

Host: On the surface, right? Not--

Doug Archer: Yeah, all on the surface.

Host: Okay.

Doug Archer: So the arm is digging, and it goes to dump, and it just so happened to choose a path between the dig location and the dump location that there was a rock in between-- it wasn’t a big rock. I mean, it was maybe 8 to 10 centimeters across-- not a huge rock. But so on like the very first scoop-- and it was supposed to be-- supposed to scoop for a while. On the very first scoop, it grabs a scoop of dirt, hits the rock, and just stops. Because it doesn’t know what to do, right? And we didn’t program it to say, okay, well, if you hit a rock, then try this other path.

Host: The only thing it knew was okay, you go from here, and you go to here. It wasn’t expecting an interruption.

Doug Archer: Yeah, so that’s the kind of thing-- and then you go in the next day and you see that, wow, things didn’t go as planned. We only had this one tiny little scoop. There was supposed to be a whole trench there-- what happened? And you go look at your telemetry and say, “oh, we hit a rock.” And it wasn’t even a very big rock. And that’s the kind of thing where for a human, right, “oh, I hit a rock. I’ll slightly move my hand and go around the rock.” And you don’t waste an entire day from hitting a small rock. And we encounter stuff like that all the time, because again, the robot’s only as smart as we are. If we encounter something unexpected, the conservative approach is usually to say, “okay, just stop, and we’ll tell you what to do tomorrow.” So a human doesn’t have those kind of limitations. As you’re saying, we have the observational ability to first of all analyze the landscape and say, “those look like the most interesting places to go investigate. Let’s go there.” And then you can go do things very quickly. And so the pace of exploration with humans can be a lot faster. Now, the cost is also a lot higher.

Host: Sure.

Doug Archer: So you’ve got to figure out kind of what’s your science return per dollar. But the pace of explorations with humans can be much, much faster.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: So like, as another example, the curiosity rover, the Mars science laboratory, which has been on Mars now for almost five years.

Host: Wow, that’s right.

Doug Archer: We have driven just over 16 kilometers, which is a long ways, but for a human and a human class rover, that would probably be a good day or two of driving.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: Now, you know, we’ve done a whole lot of science along the way, so you can’t-- it’s not just we landed and we’ve been doing nothing but driving.

Host: Hit the gas pedal and just go for--

Doug Archer: For five years, yeah. But just to give kind of a sense of scale. I think we-- the opportunity rover relatively recently surpassed how far the Apollo astronauts had driven on the moon.

Host: Wow.

Doug Archer: And so I think it took opportunity over ten years what the Apollo astronauts did in like three days.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: So you can see that there’s a sense of-- there’s this difference in scale of kind of what you can accomplish, and it’s interesting, that you’ll find that a lot of people that have experience with robotic exploration, actually operating the rovers, many, many, many of us are big proponents of human exploration because we understand the limitations, because we know just how much more we could learn and how much more we could do with humans there.

Host: Yeah. So I’m getting-- so as a planetary scientist-- I guess we should’ve addressed this a while ago, but you-- do you pick the locations where the rovers are going to go? And which rovers are you kind of working with now? Are you working with curiosity?

Doug Archer: Yeah, so right now, I’m working with curiosity. The only other rover that’s currently operational is the opportunity rover.

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: Which is amazing. It’s been going for more than 13 years now.

Host: Yeah, way past its expected--

Doug Archer: Yeah, the prime mission was supposed to be 90 days. So they’re like 4,000% of lifetime or something-- I forget the number.

Host: Awesome.

Doug Archer: But much, much, much longer than they ever expected, which is just great, and a testament to the engineers that built the rover. So I work on curiosity, and the way that the landing site selection process works is it’s actually a fairly democratic process. They’ll have multiple meetings for years in advance of launch for scientists to come, and you can propose to land wherever you want. You can say-- well, okay, within reason. So the engineers will say, “okay, for this lander it needs to be within 30 degrees of the equator, or 45 degrees of the equator,” or whatever, and you have to be able to fit a landing ellipse that’s this size. And so the landing ellipse defines-- is the area in which you are confident your lander is going to land. So, say, for the MER rovers, the landing ellipse was like 100 kilometers long and -- I don’t remember-- 15 kilometers wide or something like that. So you’d have to say, “all right, you have to find a place where we can safely land anywhere inside of a 100-kilometer-long ellipse by 20 kilometers wide. And MSL, because we got better at guidance during entry, the landing ellipse was only like 12 kilometers long I think and a few kilometers wide. So a factor of 10 improvement over what we’d done before, which opened up a whole host of other landing sites.

Host: Because now you don’t have to worry about things being in the way.

Doug Archer: Yeah, you don’t have to--

Host: A hundred kilometers kind of ellipse.

Doug Archer: You can pick a lot more interesting places because your safety requirements are relaxed from just kind of the physical geography standpoint.

Host: Mm-hmm.

Doug Archer: But so given those restrictions, you can propose anywhere you want.

Host: Mm-hmm.

Doug Archer: And you can-- so you’ll go and you advocate, you make your presentation, and you advocate for this particular site, and why your site is better than any of the other ones, the questions that we’re going to address by landing there, why this site best meets NASA’s goals and the goals of the planetary science community. And so, I mean, I think they start out with a list of like 30 to 50 landing sites, or something like that. And over time it’ll get narrowed down to usually around 3 or 4. And then what happens is there will kind of be like a community consensus around, “this is our top pick.” So that’s kind of the democratic side of things, but then ultimately the decision is made-- I’m not exactly sure who, but program officer level, NASA headquarter level, where they’ll say-- because sometimes a scientist will pick things that are like, “this is really interesting, but it’s a little bit riskier than some other site.” And for the scientists we say, “yeah, we want to do it.” And NASA headquarters might come in and say, “guys, it’s a lot more important for us to land safely then to answer this particular question.”

Host: Right.

Doug Archer: “so we’re going to choose this site.”

Host: Okay.

Doug Archer: But for the most part, it’s very democratic about basically anybody with a good idea can submit a candidate landing site, and then it gets talked about in the community for years. You analyze it for safety. We actually use our orbital assets that are around Mars now to take a lot of pictures of it to make sure for safety reasons that it’s safe. Like, another little anecdote with phoenix we had one-- we had four candidate landing sites and the top, I’m almost positive if I’m remembering correctly, the top-- we had decided on one landing site of, “okay, we think this one’s going to be the best.” And then we had the HiRISE camera get to Mars kind of right at the tail end of this process. So we didn’t have the high enough resolution-- we didn’t have as high a resolution pictures as we do today. So HiRISE, one of its top priorities was evaluating these phoenix-- potential phoenix landing sites. And this one that we had decided was going to be our top site, the principal investigator of the HiRISE image-- instrument, which is also built at the university of Arizona, where the phoenix lander was. The PIF HiRISE was a good friend with the principal investigator of phoenix and he sent an email with the picture of this landing site and it was filled with massive boulders. There were just below the limit of resolution of this other camera and it would’ve been an awful, awful place to land. So at that point, like okay, all of the other arguments are thrown out because it’s not safe.

Host: Oh, yeah.

Doug Archer: And so we went to I think plan b and they imaged that one and it was like, “yeah, that one. That one looks good.”

Host: Wow. Okay, that would’ve been-- yeah. That would’ve been not good.

Doug Archer: I mean, I think as I recall, we got the image around Halloween, so he sent it with the caption of like, “happy Halloween.” And the whole thing was like shaded red or orange or something to make it look even scarier than it actually was.

Host: Wow.

Doug Archer: So yeah, at that point we knew, “okay, that’s not-- we’re not going to land there. Let’s go somewhere else.”

Host: Wow. So, I mean, there’s rovers all over the place, right? It’s just you said we’ve been landing on Mars since the late ‘70s, since ‘76 I think you said was the Viking, right?

Doug Archer: Yeah.

Host: So there’s a lot of interesting things about Mars. So, I mean, main question, right, so if you’re looking at Mars and you want to know, “okay, what is this planet? Why is it so interesting?”

Doug Archer: Uh-huh.

Host: Main question: why is it that red or burnt orangey color?

Doug Archer: Yeah.

Host: Like, what is the official color of Mars?

Doug Archer: Well, red.

Host: Red.

Doug Archer: I mean, that’s one of Mars’ nicknames is the red planet.

Host: Right, okay.

Doug Archer: I mean, that’s when I’m writing stuff about Mars I will frequently call it the red planet just to avoid repeating Mars or Martian over and over again.

Host: Yeah.

Doug Archer: So Mars gets its red color really from essentially rust.

Host: Oh.